top of page
Search

Workers Comp: The Claim Looks Bogus, but the Carrier Keeps Paying. Why?

Mark Ess
Oct 28
1 min read

We hear it from clients all the time. Their guy is out on a comp claim, officially too hurt to work, and they get video of him lifting heavy things, or what looks like proof he's working somewhere else. They send it all to the carrier, convinced the claim is dead.

And the carrier pays anyway.

So what's going on? Is it possible that fighting just costs too much? Defense attorneys, investigators, medical exams, hearings that drag on for months. When the claim is small, maybe paying is cheaper than winning.

A video doesn't automatically prove fraud or rule out a real injury. But employers deserve to understand why their evidence did or didn't change the decision.

And here's the part that makes contractors suspicious. A claim can affect your experience mod and future premiums for several years. Not the carrier's premiums. Yours. Switching insurers doesn't erase that history. Across the industry, claims experience also helps shape future pricing, though that isn't the same as getting each payout back. At the end of the day, if that claim raises your premium, YOU are helping pay for the payout!

So does that structure influence the decision to fight or pay? Is there a conflict between what's economical for the carrier and what's best for the employer?

Just wondering..........

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page